I saw it. And I have to tell you, I didn't hate it. I was prepared to hate it, had read reviews instructing me in just HOW to hate it, and was hating it somewhat before it even started. Only went because my team at work was going, and I'm One Of The Boys. That's the kind of good times Gus I am. I mean, Hayden Christianson--oh sure, I hate HIM. And the faux Shakespearean script with the stiff and forced dialogue--yes, yes. Hate, hate. And the point where Darth Vader pulls a Luke Skywalker and yells "Nooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"? Well, duh. Of course. Abominable. Giant leaps in reason and motivation, like when Anakin suddenly decides that KILLING his old Jedi buddies is desirable? Bad and hate. But did I hate this film? No, no I did not.
Ben didn't strike me as a cardboard cutout, like a guy trying to imitate Sir Guinness. Yoda wasn't as hammy or cartoony as he's been. Hayden Christianson wasn't as... oh wait. Yeah, that guy sucked. But that emperor guy! He was great!
Favorite, lame, quotable line: "Hold me, Anakin. Hold me like you used to on Naboo." Genius.
Most everything that didn't have talking connected to it in this film was good. Fighting-good! Ships and transportation-good! Creatures and gak and stuff-good! The ability of two humans to go for extended periods of time 3 inches from rivers of lava--well, not as good.
Was this a great movie? Oh good grief no. Was it fun for somebody who loved the old films and thinks the new films were steaming piles of nutty poo? Yes, I have to say yes it was. Is Mr. Lucas as out of touch as ever? Yes. Have you had raisins to eat today? How'd you know? Yes I have!
I don't care if you go see the big Blockbuster Box Office Smash anytime soon, or if you duck out of work on a Thursday morning to watch the special 10 a.m. showing. I don't care, because there's nothing Big Picture or redeeming or meaningful in this film. I'm just telling you I had a good time, and was fascinated that I did. Scoop!